Over-the-counter vitamins for COVID-19 are unproven

Table of Contents

The claim: Melatonin, aspirin, vitamins, zinc and quercetin can prevent or treat COVID-19

Since the early stages of the pandemic, people have claimed supplements like zinc, vitamin D and melatonin can help treat and prevent COVID-19.

The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recommends getting vaccinated or taking preventative measures like wearing a face mask to minimize the chances of contracting the coronavirus. But unproven, at-home products remain popular for many.

For example, an Aug. 25 Facebook post with more than 25,000 shares features a list of what it calls “over the counter vitamins for Covid,” including vitamin C, vitamin D, melatonin, zinc, aspirin and quercetin.

“At home vitamin regimen,” reads the post’s caption. “This is not a political post.”

Fact check:Pfizer’s coronavirus vaccine is FDA-approved; cigarettes are not

But public health organizations and experts say there is little evidence these products are effective at treating or preventing COVID-19.

The Facebook user who shared the post did not return a request for comment.

Vitamins C, D

Several studies have looked at whether vitamins C and D can help prevent or treat COVID-19. But experts say more research is needed to determine if the supplements are beneficial.

Dr. William Schaffner, medical director for the National Foundation for Infectious Diseases, previously told USA TODAY there’s no convincing evidence vitamins C and D can prevent or treat COVID-19.

Fact check:‘Who’s vaccinated?’ All living presidents, governors; not most COVID-19 victims

A study published in March included 240 hospitalized patients with moderate to severe COVID-19 cases and found that a single oral dose of vitamin D did not significantly reduce the length of hospital stay compared to participants who were given a placebo.

Harvard Medical School says vitamin D may provide protection against COVID-19 because it increases natural defense against viruses and prevents an exaggerated inflammatory response. However, “a specific antiviral effect remains unproven,” the school says on its website.

Similarly, experts at Cochrane, an international organization that reviews medical research, found “the evidence for the effectiveness of vitamin D supplementation for the treatment of COVID-19 is very uncertain.”

The evidence supporting the use of vitamin C is even shakier.

Harvard Medical School warns there is no evidence taking vitamin C will prevent COVID-19. While standard doses are “generally harmless,” high doses can cause nausea, cramps and an increased risk of kidney stones, according to the school.

The National Institutes of Health’s COVID-19 Treatment Guidelines panel says there is insufficient evidence to recommend for or against the use of vitamin C in COVID-19 patients. Likewise, the Mayo Clinic says vitamin C is “unlikely to affect your immune function or prevent you from getting sick.”

Zinc, Melatonin

The NIH says there is insufficient evidence supporting the use of zinc to treat or prevent the virus and “recommends against using zinc supplementation above the recommended dietary allowance.”

A small clinical trial that used high doses of zinc and vitamin C in non-hospitalized COVID-19 patients ended early because it failed to show any benefits, USA TODAY reported in March.

Fact check: Comparing Pfizer vaccine approval to cigarettes, alcohol is wrong

Further, a study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association found no evidence that zinc alone, or combined with other supplements, would decrease COVID-19 symptoms compared to standard care.

Fewer studies have looked at the effect of melatonin, a supplement used to treat insomnia.

A Cleveland Clinic study found melatonin reduced the chances of a positive COVID-19 test. But the study was observational, and it did not prove the supplement had any benefits for treating COVID-19.

“Large-scale observational studies and randomized controlled trials are critical to validate the clinical benefit of melatonin for patients with COVID-19,” Dr. Feixong Cheng, the study’s lead author, said in a November news release.

Aspirin

Some research has associated aspirin with improved outcomes for hospitalized COVID-19 patients. But researchers say more study is needed to determine whether aspirin has an effect on the coronavirus.

An April article published in Family Medicine and Community Health recommends a low-dose aspirin regimen for patients ages 40 to 70 who are at a higher risk. However, the authors wrote randomized, controlled trials are needed to prove “aspirin’s protective roles in COVID-19 associated with acute lung injury, vascular thrombosis without previous cardiovascular disease and mortality.”

USA TODAY has previously debunked claims that the coronavirus is bacterial and can be treated easily with aspirin.

Fact check: False claim that the FDA was involved in the controversial Tuskegee study

Quercetin

Quercetin is a plant pigment that contains antioxidant properties and may reduce inflammation, allergy symptoms and blood pressure. Some recent studies have found promising results for its use in treating COVID-19, but rigorous clinical trial data is lacking, experts say.

Dr. Chris D’Adamo, director of the Center for Integrative Medicine at University of Maryland’s School of Medicine, said while more studies are needed on COVID-19 and dietary supplements, “there is already compelling evidence” that supplements including quercetin appear to reduce the severity of a COVID-19 case.

D’Adamo pointed to a Jan. 28 study published in the Journal of Inflammation, which found that quercetin “can be a potential treatment for severe inflammation, which is the main life-threatening condition in patients with COVID-19.” Similarly, another study in the International Journal of General Medicine, which examined 42 patients in Pakistan not severely affected by the virus, found quercetin can potentially help in the early stages of a COVID-19 infection and prevent progression due to its antiviral and antioxidant properties.

“One of the reasons that vitamin D, vitamin C, zinc, and quercetin is a sensible approach in optimizing the immune system against COVID is that there are complementary mechanisms among these nutrients,” D’Adamo said via email. “They have a long track record of safety having been commercially available for many years and taken by millions of people with minimal adverse events reported.”

Other studies have also found that quercetin can play a role when it comes to infections.

A paper published in June in the International Journal of General Medicine found quercetin “could aid in improving the early symptoms and help in preventing the severity of COVID-19 disease.”

Another paper from July found a daily dose of quercetin over the course of two weeks “significantly improves some of the clinical outcomes considered …(while) at the same time being very-well tolerated by users.”

However, experts note that the authors in the two papers have potential commercial conflicts of interest. And clinical trial data on quercetin is lacking.

David M. Aronoff, director of the division of infectious diseases at Vanderbilt University, told MedPage Today in July 2020 that preclinical data demonstrated antiviral activity. But Aronoff said quercetin “should be subjected to rigorous clinical study and not recommended for use outside of clinical trials.”

Over-the-counter vitamins for COVID-19 are unproven

Written by

Virgina Scherzer

Written by

Virgina Scherzer

Related Post

Whole Foodstuff Natural vitamins Vs Artificial

Mount Sinai Well being Technique Generates Much more Than $28 Million in Medicare Price savings by New York Healthcare Partners ACO

Uninsured Charge Regular But High Extra Operate Essential